The Undistinguished Scholar of the Amish, Werner Enninger, -or- Has the Time Yet Come for Rigorous Theory in Amish Studies?

Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies

Anderson, Cory. 2017.

5(2):196-238.

Research Points
  • German semiotician Werner Enninger’s theoretically rich work has been neglected, perhaps due to his work’s technicality and publication in obscure outlets. Yet, his work is brilliant; this review rectifies his neglect by synthesizing his 30+ English language publications about the Amish into a meta-theory.

  • Enninger’s meta-theory fuses structural functionalism and symbolic interactionism, linking macro structures to micro interactions to explain stability and change.

  • Central is (a) the concept of the Amish “superstructure” consisting of (b) values like community and separation that shape (c) concrete norms and expectations around roles that are (d) internalized and produce (e) the Amish role system.

  • (f) Shared knowledge of role attributes allows for (g) identification of roles during interactions, distributing privileges and obligations.

  • Roles can be obligatory (central), optional (peripheral), or forbidden; attributes like dress, language, and buggies signal roles individuals take on in interactions.

  • (h) Repeated interactions reproducing roles and expectations reinforce the stability of the social system.

  • In central realms with institutionalized events, roles are ascribed and fixed (role-taking); in peripheral diffuse realm with non-institutionalized events, roles are negotiable (role-making) and norms are vague, which allows for gradual social change.

  • Language choice of Pennsylvania German, English, or High German depends on the roles individuals take on during interactions.

Access Related Content From The Project: "Reviews by Topic"

Amish Education: A Synthesis

Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist
Studies
Anderson, Cory. 2015.
3(1):1-24.

Links & Details

Review Essay of Horse-and-Buggy Genius[Loewen], Pennsylvania Dutch [Louden], and The Amish [Nolt]

Rural Sociology
Anderson, Cory, and Joseph Donnermeyer. 2018.
83(2):470-77.

Links & Details

A Critical Appraisal of Amish Studies’ De Facto Paradigm, ‘Negotiating with Modernity’

Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
Anderson, Cory, Joseph Donnermeyer, Jeffrey Longhofer, and Steven D. Reschly. 2019.
58(3):725-42.

Links & Details

Amish Language Research: A Review

Handbook of the Changing World Language Map, edited by Stanley D. Brunn and Roland Kehrein. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Anderson, Cory. 2019. Pp. 939-61

Links & Details

The Amish Health Culture and Culturally Sensitive Health Services: An Exhaustive Narrative Review.

Social Science & Medicine
Anderson, Cory, and Lindsey Potts. 2020.
265:113466.

Links & Details

Physical Health Conditions of the Amish and Intervening Social Mechanisms: An Exhaustive Narrative Review.

Ethnicity & Health
Anderson, Cory, and Lindsey Potts. 2022.
27(8):1952-78.

Links & Details

The Cultural and Religious Complexities of Amish-Focused Mental Health Conditions Research: Insights from an Exhaustive Narrative Review and Case Study of Counseling Controversies.

Mental Health, Religion & Culture.
Anderson, Cory, and Lindsey Potts.

Links & Details
woman preparing a meal

The Work of Pioneering Amish Studies Scholar Walter Kollmorgen: Annotations of His 1940s Amish Publications

Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies
Anderson, Cory. 2023.
11(1):95-105.

Links & Details
© 2025 • Cory Anderson • All Rights Reserved