Religious Seekers’ Attraction to the Plain Mennonites and Amish

Review of Religious Research

Anderson, Cory. 2016.

58(1):125-47.

Research Points
  • In just over a year’s time, 1,000+ people filled out a survey to receive information about local plain church, thus expressing potential interest in joining plain Anabaptist groups such as the Beachy Amish-Mennonites, Conservative Mennonites, or Amish.

  • Of religious backgrounds, 21.8% were Baptist, 50% were evangelical, and 28.3% were non- affiliated Christians

  • Top attractions included “serious Christian faith” (69%), “strong community” (69%), and “modesty” (65%)

  • Seekers tend to have either direct experience with plain people and their media (e.g. church periodicals) or indirect exposure through popular representations, such as Amish-themed novels and tourist venues

  • A factor analysis revealed six overarching seeker interests:

(1) Family Control: Value parental control over child socialization & consolidated social domains around family;
(2) Femininity: Drawn to distinctive gender roles & symbols like head coverings; alternative to mainstream sexualized culture
(3) Personal Conviction: Prioritize Biblical literalism & personal morality
(4) Primitivism: Appreciate simplicity, technology restraint, back-to-earth lifestyle
(5) Stability: Perceive order & stability of groups; some seek help getting life “on track”
(6) Returnees: Want to rejoin childhood faith or connect with Anabaptist ancestry

 

  • Females were the significant majority (69%); young women especially were drawn to plain groups’ countercultural standards around gender and modesty as an alternative to mainstream youth culture

Access Related Content From The Project: "Public Perceptions"

Evaluation and Revision of an Instrument Measuring Attitudes toward the Amish

Journal of Applied Social Science
Anderson, Cory, and Lee Decker. 2020.
14(2):195-211.

Links & Details
© 2024 • Cory Anderson • All Rights Reserved